34 thoughts on “How Do I Pick a Fly Color? (feat. Kelly Galloup)”

  1. @BlueSageJake says:

    WOW! Great Stuff. I am new to fly fishing and I have devoured a bunch of Mad River videos. I learn so much from each of these. In fact, I learn so much that I probably forget 50% of it once I am knee deep in the water and excited about catching fish! But, I figure that fly fishing is an art form, a lifelong pursuit, and a lifetime of learning. This is exactly what makes fly fishing so intriguing to me. There is just so much to learn! But, I don't expect myself to learn everything on my first outings. I am grateful that such a great resource exists that will both enhance my fishing experience and expedite my learning process. Thank You for putting out such FANTASTIC material. I am HOOKED!

  2. @michaelshaw8370 says:

    Colour. Contour. Size. Pattern. Style of pattern as in streamer, type of streamer, then winged wet, nymph, dry, bug, beast, or fry. Read the conditions. Be aware of any changes temp wind light or water condition such as upstream rain adding extra and or discoloured water. River or pond be aware. To crack the code and adapt as the fish do. The same water can have several food sources during the day and at the same time. Read what the fish are actually taking. Not what you first see.

  3. @VTbeer says:

    Please have Kelly on as much as possible. Such a no nonsense, unapologetic voice of knowledge. You are both such great story tellers, which is rare these days.

  4. @shanecouch8328 says:

    Kelly i change flies a lot but I often wonder if it gets to a point that it's counter productive because you can't catch a fish when your fly isn't in the water. I find frantically changing flies puts me in a head space that I feel I don't have confidence in any of them and don't fish them as well

  5. @thecutthroatcowboy says:

    Great advice as always. I had a guest tell me one time "I don't care if we don't catch fish, but I do care if we don't TRY to catch fish." I really took that to heart and have always made an effort since then to put my guests on fish, even if it means 100 fly changes.

  6. @RickStaight says:

    I have been fishing the Wisconsin Driftless for about 20+ years. There was one particular hole full of Brookies that has since been destroyed by one the 100 year class floods. I would start with an Adams and catch 3 fish. I would sit down and put on a Blue Wing Olive and catch 3 fish. Then put on a Sulphur and get 3 more. Then put on a March Brown, guess what 3 more. Then start over.

    For what ever reason this hole was only good for 3 fish on a fly. Then you had to change and by the time you went through those four they forgot about the first one. All of us that fished that hole did well. I really believe we caught the same fish multiple times.

  7. @andymeadows280 says:

    Really enjoyed this conversation thanks
    My question is how I could apply this trout strategy to river small mouth
    I mostly fish the big central western MI rivers, Muskegon/Grand and smaller tributaries

  8. @AbrahimBen-Khalid says:

    Great videos as always, quick question though. These tactics have to change somewhat on a lower volume river like some of the rivers in the south east. We just don’t have as many fish per mile resulting in having to change color less frequently simply due to the fact that there are just less fish that see the fly? Is that accurate? Instead of changing 8 times in 15 minutes maybe changing 3 times in 15 minutes, etc. Thanks for all that you do, much love from ATL.

  9. @terrhian677 says:

    I don’t have rivers/creeks around my area. I have Ponds and Lakes all around me. Do you still go through the same rotation of color? I’ll be honest, I can’t see my flies as they sink down the water so I can’t tell if I caught the attention of any fish until they hit it. Can you give me advice how I can go through the color/fly type rotation?

  10. @JP-dz7zu says:

    I’ve had a bit of a different experience from Kelly as I enter competitive fly fishing tournaments mostly nymphing. Fish get a better look at a nymph than a streamer which is more of a reactionary bite. For nymphs I find the far ends of the color spectrum work best specifically orange and purple. If one doesn’t work I switch to the other.

    For streamers I think size and shape matter most, but I agree on color switches. I do white, black, olive or yellow until I dial the color in.

  11. @johnnylightning1491 says:

    Not being a coffee drinker, will your campfire mugs make hot chocolate taste better? Inquiring minds want to know. Also does the color of the mug make a difference? Don't apologize for having a long interview with Kelly, I always learn something from him whether it's 5 minutes or an hour and a half. Keep the good stuff coming guys.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *